‘God forbid that a dog should die’: when Goodreads reviews go bad

From cancelled books to ‘review bombing’, it might seem as though the website can make or break a career. But how influential is it really?Something dramatic happens on a social media platform every day. On Goodreads, the anachro­nistically designed website for logging, rating (out of five) and reviewing books, the dramas are more amusing, and they occasionally even draw attention from areas beyond the site’s supposedly book-loving users. The most recent featured Cait Corrain, the fantasy author who set up an elaborate network of fake accounts to post positive reviews of her own forthcoming book as well as negative reviews of authors she felt were her competitors. When citizen journalists uncovered her plot in December 2023, her book was cancelled, and she lost her agent and a future book deal.A juicy, postmodern story of self-sabotage, or a sad one about the intersection of the internet and mental health. Regardless, its stakes are relatively low: publicly harassing one’s colleagues is a sackable offence anyway, and it’s hard to find someone who really cares about the vicissitudes of the young adult literature world who isn’t part of the subculture. I’m not; I’m a professional critic, and an author of a literary novel. I’m a snob. I care about my book, and the authors I feel are my competitors. And while Goodreads has been around since 2007, its significance to the broader literary world remains steadfastly confusing. Does it sell books? Does it make and break careers?... Continue reading at 'The Guardian'

[ The Guardian | 2024-02-17 09:00:10 UTC ]

Other news stories related to: "‘God forbid that a dog should die’: when Goodreads reviews go bad"


A Small Press Book We Love: Point Zero by Seichō Matsumoto

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-28 13:15:15 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: The Fisherman by John Langan

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-27 13:15:11 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Minor Detail by Adaina Shibli

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-26 13:15:47 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Provisionally Yours by Antanas Sileika

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-25 13:15:31 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Little Blue Encyclopedia (For Vivian) by Hazel Jane Plante

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-24 13:15:01 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Loved and Missed by Susie Boyt

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-21 13:15:06 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Duplex by Kathryn Davis

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-20 13:15:38 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Let Me Clear My Throat by Elena Passarello

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-19 13:15:06 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Children of the Ghetto by Elias Khoury

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-18 13:15:56 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Margaret the First by Danielle Dutton

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-17 14:45:39 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Naples 1349 by Amedeo Feniello

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-14 13:30:40 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Pipe Dreams on Pico by Brent L. Smith

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-13 13:30:12 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: The Days of Abandonment by Elena Ferrante

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-12 13:30:55 UTC ]
More news stories like this


For its tenth birthday(!), A Little Life is getting a makeover.

Ten years ago this month, Hanya Yanagihara threw a wrench in the literary world with the publication of her Dickensian doorstop, A Little Life. Featuring four queer men growing up and together in New York high society—and also, many grim depictions of child abuse and ultra-violence—the... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-12 13:13:49 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: That We May Live: Speculative Chinese Fiction

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-11 13:30:22 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Wings in Time by Callie Garnett

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-10 13:30:00 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: The Bear by Andrew Krivak

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-06 14:28:36 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: The President’s Room by Ricardo Romero

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-05 14:30:44 UTC ]
More news stories like this


A Small Press Book We Love: Braiding Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmerer

Small presses have had a rough year, but as the literary world continues to conglomerate, we at Literary Hub think they’re more important than ever. Which is why, every (work) day in March—which just so happens to be National Small Press Month—a Lit Hub staff member will be recommending a small... Continue reading at Literrary Hub

[ Literrary Hub | 2025-03-04 14:30:00 UTC ]
More news stories like this